extra virgin olive oil ice cream

Olive oil ice cream from the Michelin-starred Cornerstone team

Though the pairing ice cream with extra virgin olive oil might sound strange at first—it is the BEST THING EVER. The olive oil makes the ice cream somehow even more creamy, smooth, and decadent.

We've been singing the praises of this combo for a while now, and testing in loads of ways. Typically this has been some store-bought vanilla ice cream with some sea salt flakes over the top. We've also tried it with a range of Hackney Gelato, and even gone vegan. Like magic, the texture of the olive oil takes your standad vegan ice cream to new lush heights.

But then the absolute dream-team that is Head Chef James Toth and the insanely-talented Pastry Chef Laura Petersen from Hackney's Michelin-starred Cornerstone gifted us with this very special recipe. 

Here they detail how to make olive oil ice cream from scratch using our single estate EVOO from Crete just like they do at Cornerstone. 

And while it might require a little bit more effort than picking up a tub of ice cream at a local grocer, this tastes worlds better and should become a staple of your next dinner party—regardless of the season!

    Here's the method:

    Serves 8-10

    • In a pan, bring the milk to a simmer with the glucose.
    • Whisk the yolks with the sugar together in a bowl.
    • Once the milk has simmered, pour it onto the egg yolk mix and whisk until combined.
    • Pour the custard back into a clean pan and cook until it coats the back of a spoon. (Exactly 82 degrees celsius if you have a probe.)
    • Take off the heat.
    • In a slow and steady stream pour in the olive oil while whisking the mix and add the salt.
    • Strain through a sieve to make the mix super smooth.
    • Churn in an ice cream machine for the best results. Alternatively, freeze in a container stirring every hour.
    • Enjoy with an extra drizzle of extra virgin olive oil and a sprinkle of salt.

    Ways to make it your own:
    • Playing around with the flavour combinations such as basil or mint.
    • Crushing in some fresh citrus or serving it in citrus "shells".


    Are you making this? Share with your fellow citizens. Tag us in your photos on Instagram at @CitizensofSoil.

    Join the Olive Oil Club

    We travel the world to seek out remarkable independent producers, sourcing some of the best olive oils out there. For a revolving selection of exclusive, small batch EVOOs...
    SHOP NOW

    You may also like...

    The Citizens’ Christmas List

    For your *extra* gift inspiration. We’ve partnered with some of our fave foodie, drinks, lifestyle, and Bcorp buddies to give you last-minute shoppers some inspiration. There’s also some *extra* special Citizens’ Christmas discounts below too...  1. The bottle for festive hosting, a bottle of Crement from drinkamie  2. A perfect pairing to our club, a pasta subscription to nonna_tonda     Use CITIZENS40 for 40% Citizens’ discount off 3 deliveries.  3. Give the pantry a glow up with to...


    Caper and anchovy tapenade with cashew cream

      Dinner party perfection. Wow your guests with these crisp, delicious, savoury tarts from Eve Seeman, Head Chef at Apricity, a Michelin Green Star restaurant in the heart of Mayfair with an ethos of conscious cooking and joyful dining.  Here's the method: Serves 4 First make your tart cases. Carefully open the filo pastry and lay it flat. Gently brush the whole surface with melted butter and lay another filo sheet on top of it, pressing down to stick them without any air bubbles. Cut th...


    Leftover turkey mac and cheese with blue cheese pangrattato

    Christmas comfort and the leftovers of champions.  If you can't stand the sight of another roast potato—this is the dish for you. A new way to use any left over Christmas meat this mac & cheese makes a welcome change to a traditional Christmas menu. For a veggie twist, or more 5-a-day, you can also add sprouts or broccoli to the bake.  This recipe is from Eve Seeman, Head Chef at Apricity, a Michelin Green Star restaurant in the heart of Mayfair with an ethos of conscious cooking and jo...


    Follow us on instagram

    x